Colts Neck Inn Hotel

I was expecting more for an 8.6 rating. This seems to be a place people stay for a short visit. Still, the rooms are very dated. The mattress had a thick plastic cover on it rendering sleeping a noisy endeavor. Not sure how they could expect somebody to sleep on it. Took it off. Air system worked fine, but it's old. Thin walls. People walking above me in their room woke me up. Property is clearly aged. Breakfast was fine. They are trying with amenities, but many updates are needed. Showers are very old. Wifi needs better protection for working.

The staff was amazing. Room very clean and comfortable. Even had flowers in room for more home feel. This trip is yearly and this is the place I always stay!!!

A very cozy, comfortable, and quiet environment. Staff made you feel welcome, complimentary coffee was always available, and the dining area was stocked 24/7 in case you got hungry or wanted coffee. Rustic, calm and tranquil environment. Dining area is also a social area and they encourage socializing. Very homey feel. Would recommend to anyone.

This was such a a wonderful stay! The suite was so amazing and comfortable... and the whirlpool tub was awesome 😎! The loveseats were wicked soft and squishy... And the staff were friendly and the bfast yummy. I can't say enough to give mad props to this property.

It definitely has charm in the lobby however once you get into the room it takes you back to the 80’s. They do seem to be updating the rooms somewhat. The first room we were given I noticed the carpet was wet by the refrigerator and some obvious white spot on it from the water. However when I told the front desk she moved us to a new room immediately and said she would tell management. Our second room was a little more updated with vinyl flooring. However the people above us must had the same as we heard them walking around. They definitely need to update the thermostat, one you had no idea what the actual temperature was and even turning it all the way to “cold still super hot. If turned off super cold. Breakfast was the similar to what you would get at a chain hotel. I will say the front desk employees were super helpful and very friendly.

Rooms are being updated and look good. Grounds could use some cleaning up. Lawn chairs in many spots turned over. Random junk in some areas up against the hotel. Will would Stay there again.

This little gem is the perfect place to stay. It is comfortable, peaceful and the staff are so helpful and welcoming.I enjoyed a two day break here and can’t wait to return in the near furure.

It’s the best option for price and quality in the area by far. The staff is friendly. The only issue is noise. The walls are very thin/not noise proof. Th first night we could hear our neighbors talking very late at night. The last night we also had noisy neighbors. I’d still recommend it for value and quality. Just bring some ear plugs or headphones with a white noise playlist streaming.

When I turned on the heat, it warmed the room quickly. The bed was real comfortable. The staff were super friendly. The place was decorated beautifully for Christmas. Coffee was always available. The Natura soap was amazing.