Inn at Starlight Lake & Restaurant

We had a lovely one-night stay, including two very satisfying meals in the restaurant. The property and location are very nice, but the inn is showing its age.

Breakfast was lovely, and the woman who served us was friendly and helpful. Bathrooms were clean but carpets and linens were not. Our shower didn’t work but they gave us a slight discount for that. Our biggest complaint was finding out three hours before checking in that the hotel was hosting a drag show the night we were checking in, and so we might have a hard time getting in the front door if we arrived between 8:30 and 10:30pm. I only found out because I called to see if they had any specific instructions for our arrival. Had I known that meant the front door would be blocked by a performer, with a whole audience watching, and that music would be blasting for the two hours, I would have asked them right then to cancel our stay. So if you stay here, I’d ask them first if there is any type of event happening while you’re there.

My friend and I booked a room at the Inn at Starlight Lake to stay at while in town for an autumnal wedding. The name sounded beautiful alone, and the inn was even better in person than in the gorgeous photos. It’s a historic inn with a great view, delicious breakfast (included), and cozy atmosphere. We got two twin beds with a hillside view, but could still see the lake from the windows! Highly recommend staying here if in town near Hancock or Long Eddy.

we loved this place so much! felt so comfortable! thank you for a wonderful experience! ＜3

This Inn was scary. I dont think windows have been washed in the last 15 years. The whole building feels like its about fall down. When my wife got in bed, she almost fell off the bed due to a heavy sloping of the floors.

Only reason to come here is lake is very good to relax and enjoy. Way too many little kids running around inside main lobby. Like a nursery. Shuffle board court in front is fun. Old bed and showers from 1960. Place has character. Only issue 2-6 years old running in fro t area all day

Was a little spooky getting there, but food and view well worth it!

Quiet and rustic. middle of nowhere on a beautiful little lake. Staff was very friendly, on site restaurant was excellent. requested non scented linens, they complied.

We had a pleasant stay. We stayed in the cottage. The furnoture was quite old but everything was very clean.The room was quite spacious as well. We ate dinner at the inn and it was delicious. The breakfast was also outstanding as well. The bartender made a very tasty drink as well. I had a mohito. I would stay again in a heartbeat!. The staff and Innkeeper was very accom