Chaffee Lodge

My wife and I were satisfied with our accommodations, and we enjoyed experiencing the area around East Aurora, New York, where we travel at least once a year. The drive from Chaffee to East Aurora is a pleasant 15 minutes, making Chaffee Lodge a viable option. Our room was clean and comfortable with working air conditioning and working windows. The manager, Scott, was most courteous and friendly. As we were packing, he came out to wish us a safe trip and to thank us, hoping to see us next year. I would definitely consider returning.

The only complaint is that the water drained SLOWLY in the bathroom sink and the toilet wouldn't flush (so I didn't try the shower). The room was clean, comfortable and spacious. This is a hunting/fishing lodge that appears to rent some rooms by the week or month. They gave me great tips on where to eat - local places, not chains. But they need to fix their water problem in the room where I stayed.

The owner was friendly. The hallway needs repainting, but the room was clean and comfortable.

The room was dirty & unkept . The bed sheets in room 5 ( April 9, 2026 ) were NOT replaced prior to our arrival. When my wife & I were about to get in bed for the night we saw that the sheets contained someones grittiness . Who in the hell wants to crawl into that ? My wife was disgusted . It's MY WIFE ! We left around 3:00 am on 04/10/26 . Tried to get a refund but they declined . Chaffee Lodge is a JOKE & so is the long bearded fast talking lobby attendant ( "manager" LoL ) Also when my wife & I returned at 9:45 pm on 04/09/26 after visiting some friends the entire lobby & hallway reeked with the smell of **** .

Great host, and very reasonable for the price. Would stay again.

Loved the welcome we got from the staff. Great job!

Was a quiet stay, good neighborhood with dining options. Room is neat. One of the beds was sagging heavily. Had no issues otherwise.

It needed a really good cleaning The bedding appeared to be clean but the bathroom was filthy the floors were dirty and had hair on them. They needed to be swept and mopped. Half the lights and fan didn't work in the bathroom. The smoke detector was missing. The floors were sticky and needed mopped and i pulled out the bedside stand to get to the plug and there was dirt and dead bugs behind it. The manager was a super nice guy thats the only good thing i can say.

This is a nice quiet motel in a very small community. The owner went out of his way to ensure we had a great stay. Offered suggestions for dining, offered to help with luggage, and ensured we were comfortable. The rooms are very dated, but the friendliness and kindness of the owner more than makes up for it! AC was cold, fridge was great to have, and the bed and pillows were absolutely perfect! Keurig coffee in the lobby with fresh creamer was always available, which was a wonderful amenity! Just a short 30 minute drive to Letchworth State Park (Grand Canyon of the East) is a must do! Kudos to the owner, he is a real gem!!